Bay Shore, NY Real Estate Market Summary – September 8, 2026
In Bay Shore, NY, the real estate market has seen 16 homes sold in the last 30 days, averaging a pace of one every 1.88 days. The average living area of these homes was approximately 1,793 square feet, with a median sale price of $725,250.
| Metric | 30 Days |
|---|---|
| Number Sold | 16 |
| Sold Per Day | 1 every 1.88 days |
| Average SQFT | 1793 |
| Median Sales Price | $725,250 |
| Average Sales Price | $727,871 |
| Average Price Per SQFT | $433 |
| Average Days on Market | 14 |
| Average Year Built | 1962 |
Bay Shore, NY Single Family Home Analysis
For single-family homes in Bay Shore, 14 properties were sold recently. The average days on market for these homes was around 13, with a median sale price of $710,000.
| Metric | 30 Days |
|---|---|
| Number Sold | 14 |
| Sold Per Day | 1 every 2.14 days |
| Average SQFT | 1746 |
| Median Sales Price | $710,000 |
| Average Sales Price | $715,388 |
| Average Price Per SQFT | $436 |
| Average Days on Market | 13 |
| Average Year Built | 1955 |
Bay Shore, NY Condo & Townhome Analysis
In the condo and townhome segment, 2 units sold, with an average sale price of $815,250. Notably, these properties had an average living area of 2,118 square feet and spent about 20 days on the market before closing.
| Metric | 30 Days |
|---|---|
| Number Sold | 2 |
| Sold Per Day | 1 every 15.00 days |
| Average SQFT | 2118 |
| Median Sales Price | $815,250 |
| Average Sales Price | $815,250 |
| Average Price Per SQFT | $409 |
| Average Days on Market | 20 |
| Average Year Built | 2006 |
Buyer & Seller Analysis
- Average sale price for all homes is $727,871.
- Condos/townhomes had higher average pricing at $815,250.
- Average days on market for all properties was 14 days.
- Single-family homes showed a pace of 1 every 2.14 days.
Conclusion
Overall, the market in Bay Shore reflects a consistent activity level in home transactions. The average sale prices indicate a range of options for potential buyers.