Middle Island, NY Real Estate Market Summary – September 8, 2026
In Middle Island, NY, there were 18 homes sold in the past 30 days, with an average sale price of $474,079 and a median sale price of $502,500. Homes in this area have an average living space of 1,547 square feet and were typically built around 1980.
| Metric | 30 Days |
|---|---|
| Number Sold | 18 |
| Sold Per Day | 1 every 1.67 days |
| Average SQFT | 1547 |
| Median Sales Price | $502,500 |
| Average Sales Price | $474,079 |
| Average Price Per SQFT | $307 |
| Average Days on Market | 17 |
| Average Year Built | 1980 |
Middle Island, NY Single Family Home Analysis
Specifically for single-family homes, 9 properties were sold, featuring an average sale price of $614,556 and a median of $635,000. These homes averaged 1,960 square feet and were generally built in the late 1970s, with an average of 15 days on the market before sale.
| Metric | 30 Days |
|---|---|
| Number Sold | 9 |
| Sold Per Day | 1 every 3.33 days |
| Average SQFT | 1960 |
| Median Sales Price | $635,000 |
| Average Sales Price | $614,556 |
| Average Price Per SQFT | $321 |
| Average Days on Market | 15 |
| Average Year Built | 1977 |
Middle Island, NY Condo & Townhome Analysis
In the condo and townhome segment, 9 properties sold with an average sale price of $333,603 and a median of $250,000. The average living area for these homes was about 1,134 square feet, and they were mostly constructed in the early 1980s, taking an average of 19 days on the market.
| Metric | 30 Days |
|---|---|
| Number Sold | 9 |
| Sold Per Day | 1 every 3.33 days |
| Average SQFT | 1134 |
| Median Sales Price | $250,000 |
| Average Sales Price | $333,603 |
| Average Price Per SQFT | $292 |
| Average Days on Market | 19 |
| Average Year Built | 1982 |
Buyer & Seller Analysis
- 1 new listing every 1.67 days in the overall market
- Average of 17 days on market for all homes
- Average sale price is $474,079 across all segments
- No sales data for properties currently listed
Conclusion
Overall, the market in Middle Island demonstrates consistent activity, with properties being sold within a reasonable time frame. This data provides insights into the local housing landscape for potential buyers and sellers alike.