Middletown, NJ Real Estate Market Summary – September 8, 2026

In Middletown, NJ, the real estate market had 31 homes sold in the last 30 days, averaging 1.03 properties sold per day. The average days on market were about 18, with homes typically featuring a living area of approximately 2,183 square feet.

Metric 30 Days
Number Sold 31
Sold Per Day 1.03
Average SQFT 2183
Median Sales Price $875,000
Average Sales Price $972,872
Average Price Per SQFT $427
Average Days on Market 18
Average Year Built 1971

 

Middletown, NJ Single Family Home Analysis

For single-family homes, 29 properties were sold, with an average sale price of $972,380 and an average living area of 2,129 square feet. These homes averaged 18 days on the market before being sold.

Metric 30 Days
Number Sold 29
Sold Per Day 1 every 1.03 days
Average SQFT 2129
Median Sales Price $875,000
Average Sales Price $972,380
Average Price Per SQFT $434
Average Days on Market 18
Average Year Built 1969

 

Middletown, NJ Condo & Townhome Analysis

In the condo and townhome segment, only 2 properties sold, each averaging 2,866 square feet in living area. These properties had an average sale price of $980,000 and spent about 14 days on the market.

Metric 30 Days
Number Sold 2
Sold Per Day 1 every 15.00 days
Average SQFT 2866
Median Sales Price $980,000
Average Sales Price $980,000
Average Price Per SQFT $341
Average Days on Market 14
Average Year Built 2021

 

Buyer & Seller Analysis

  • 31 homes sold in the past 30 days
  • Average days on market for all homes was 18
  • Median sale price across all segments was $875,000
  • Real estate data does not disclose individual sale prices

Conclusion

Overall, the Middletown real estate market is characterized by a moderate level of activity with varied properties selling within a consistent time frame. The single-family home segment dominates the number of sales compared to condos and townhomes.

Subscribe here to more in-depth analysis and reporting.
Your first name so we know who to address.