Shelter Island, NY Real Estate Market Summary – September 8, 2026
In the Shelter Island real estate market, 2 homes were reported sold within the last 30 days. The average living area of these homes was 1,999 square feet, with an average sale price of $1,530,000.
| Metric | 30 Days |
|---|---|
| Number Sold | 2 |
| Sold Per Day | 1 every 15.00 days |
| Average SQFT | 1999 |
| Median Sales Price | $1,530,000 |
| Average Sales Price | $1,530,000 |
| Average Price Per SQFT | $778 |
| Average Days on Market | 14 |
| Average Year Built | 1968 |
Shelter Island, NY Single Family Home Analysis
The single-family home segment had 2 homes sold, also averaging a living area of 1,999 square feet and a median sale price of $1,530,000. The homes in this category spent an average of 13.5 days on the market.
| Metric | 30 Days |
|---|---|
| Number Sold | 2 |
| Sold Per Day | 1 every 15.00 days |
| Average SQFT | 1999 |
| Median Sales Price | $1,530,000 |
| Average Sales Price | $1,530,000 |
| Average Price Per SQFT | $778 |
| Average Days on Market | 14 |
| Average Year Built | 1968 |
Shelter Island, NY Condo & Townhome Analysis
There is no market data available for that home type at this time.
Buyer & Seller Analysis
- Pace of listings is 1 every 15.00 days.
- Average days on market for sold homes is 14.
- Median sale price for homes is $1,530,000.
- No recent sales data for condo or townhome segments.
Conclusion
Overall, the Shelter Island market is currently experiencing minimal activity, with only two sales reported in the last month. Potential sellers may want to consider the current average days on market and pricing trends.